Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu (Update 2026)

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta offers a vast selection of delectable dishes that cater to all taste buds. You can choose from classic pizzas like Sicilian, Margherita, and Buffalo Chicken, each crafted with fresh ingredients and plenty of flavor. For those craving something hearty, deep dish options and specialty pies are available, emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to quality.

Hot heroes, ranging from Sausage Peppers 'N Eggs to Shrimp Parmigiana, highlight the Italian-American influence in the menu. Seafood lovers can delight in dishes like Shrimp Scampi and Seafood Combo dinners, while chicken dinners like Chicken Francese and Chicken Sorrento provide comforting choices at a reasonable price.

Veggies and salad enthusiasts can explore classic salads or specialty versions like Gabby's Special Salad.

With an impressive total of 218 dishes and an average price of $21.82, there's plenty to taste at Gabby's. Whether seeking a quick bite or a full meal, Gabby's stands out as a local favorite for its generous portions and variety, making it an essential stop on Main Street.

Hot Heros
Seafood Dinners
Cheesesteaks
Desserts
Classic Salads
Pan Pizza
Tacos Birria with Cheese
Chicken Dinners
Sicilian
Super Bowl Specials
Veal Dinners
Pasta Dinners
Carne Asada
Specialty Pizza
Appetizers
Italian Rolls
Wraps
Specialty Salads
Calzone
Paninis
Cold Heros
Drinks
Party Trays
Side Orders
Pizza
Soup

Featured Dishes

Pizza by the Slice
Pizza by the Slice
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Gabby's Soda
Gabby's Soda
Calamari
Calamari
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Carne Asada
Carne Asada
Meat Pizza
Meat Pizza
Gabby's Special Panini
Gabby's Special Panini
Sicilian Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Slice of Pizza
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 1
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 2
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 3
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 4
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 5
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 6
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 7
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 8
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Menu image 9
Gabby's Pizza & Pasta

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Interior, Food, Ambiance

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta invites diners into a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for families and groups of friends. The interior balances casual dining with an inviting charm; brick walls adorned with local artwork hint at the neighborhood's rich culture. Comfortable seating arrangements allow for both intimate meals and lively group gatherings, providing a flexible dining experience to suit any occasion.

The ambiance buzzes with energy, fueled by happy conversations and the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. Conversations drift easily as the friendly staff moves around, ensuring that every customer feels welcomed and valued.

As you savor the meal, the aroma of the ovens adds to the enjoyment, setting the stage for memorable dining moments.

From takeout to sit-down meals, Gabby's offers a slice of comfort that feels like home. The vibrant atmosphere combined with delicious food makes it not only a meal stop but a beloved community gathering place on Main Street, Flemington.

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta

About Gabby's Pizza & Pasta Food and Specialties

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta specializes in a delightful fusion of traditional Italian recipes and modern comfort food. The array of pizzas serves as a major draw for locals, with highlights including the beloved Sicilian pie and the popular deep dish that provides a satisfying depth of flavor. Regulars consistently rave about the Buffalo Chicken pizza—its spicy and savory combination hits the spot for those who want something more adventurous.

Beyond pizza, the diverse menu features hot heroes loaded with toppings that go beyond the ordinary. Items like the Fresh Mozzarella with Roasted Peppers and the Meatball Parmigiana Hero shine, showcasing quality ingredients that keep patrons happily coming back.

Additionally, Gabby's takes pride in their pasta options, with dishes like Fettuccine Alfredo and Penne 'N Vodka sauce always well-received and perfect for a comforting dinner.

Each dish reflects the restaurant's commitment to freshness and quality—a trademark that keeps Gabby's at the top of the local favorites list.

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta

Gabby's Pizza & Pasta embodies a commitment to quality that resonates with every bite. The specialty items on the menu celebrate Italian heritage while embracing local tastes, showcasing the restaurant's dedication to community. The vision of Gabby's positions it as more than just a dining spot; it nurtures a space for neighbors to connect, share meals, and create memories. This commitment to crafting delicious food with passion ensures that each dish is made to order, with attention to detail that enhances every experience.

Gabby's isn’t just about filling stomachs; it passionately fuels connections among diners and the community itself. This dedication sets Gabby’s apart, as it continues to thrive in the heart of Flemington.